June is Annuity Awareness Month. It brings confident arguments both for and against annuities. A useful response is to ask what job a particular contract would do, what it costs, what you give up, and how the person recommending it is paid. Ask those questions of me too.
Consider the Incentives on Both Sides
An advisor paid on assets under management may earn less when money leaves a billed portfolio. An insurance producer may earn a commission when an annuity is purchased. Some contracts and business models use ongoing fees, trails, or other arrangements. Compensation can create conflicts in either direction; it does not establish that a recommendation is right or wrong.
Ask for the actual compensation, including commissions, ongoing fees, any difference among the alternatives, and the cost of a replacement. A commission may be paid by the insurer rather than separately invoiced to you, but product economics still matter. Do not infer a firm’s motives, or the quality of its advice, from its business model alone.
Following the money identifies a question to ask. The contract and the household’s needs determine the answer.
Different Contracts, Different Jobs
- Immediate income annuity: exchanges a premium for a payment stream beginning soon. Payment duration and survivor or refund provisions determine what remains for a beneficiary.
- Deferred income annuity: starts the payment stream later. It may also use a life-only, survivor, refund, or period-certain form, depending on the contract.
- MYGA: a fixed deferred annuity guaranteeing an interest rate for a stated term. It is an insurance contract, not an FDIC-insured CD. Surrender charges, market-value adjustments, withdrawal rules, renewal terms, and issuer strength matter.
- Fixed indexed annuity: credits interest under an index-linked formula. Caps, participation rates, spreads, and renewal provisions can limit growth. It does not invest the owner directly in the index, and protection from index losses does not remove every possible reduction in value.
- Lifetime withdrawal rider: an optional feature on some deferred annuities that may support withdrawals for life under specified conditions, often for a fee. Excess withdrawals or other actions can reduce or end the guarantee.
Labels such as “income FIA” or “guaranteed income FIA” do not describe separate universal legal categories. Read the actual base contract and rider. Guarantees depend on the insurer’s claims-paying ability, and a rating is not a guarantee.
What Happens at Death?
The answer depends on the payout choice and the contract. A life-only income annuity, immediate or deferred, generally stops at death without a remaining-account payment. Refund, period-certain, or survivor features can provide specified payments to beneficiaries or another annuitant. They do not all promise the same remaining value.
A deferred annuity may pay a contractual death benefit or remaining account value. Withdrawals, fees, and other contract provisions can reduce it, possibly to zero. A lifetime income guarantee can continue after the account value is exhausted while leaving no account value for heirs. The “income benefit base” used to calculate payments is generally a bookkeeping measure, not cash available to withdraw or a promised inheritance.
Fit Comes Before a Quote
Within the REGAL Stronghold™, an annuity may support a defined Foundation income need. Start with dependable income after tax, essential spending, survivor needs, inflation, and available liquidity. Compare the contract with keeping a pension, changing Social Security timing, holding a bond or CD ladder, or using a diversified portfolio. Sometimes the existing plan needs no annuity.
Buying an annuity inside an IRA does not add another layer of tax deferral to the IRA. Any case for the purchase must rest on its other benefits and costs. For a household near retirement, surrender periods and access to emergency funds deserve particular attention.
The Questions to Bring to the Table
- When does income begin, for whose life, and what happens after the first death?
- Which values and payments are guaranteed, and which depend on future crediting or assumptions?
- What are the fees, surrender charges, adjustments, withdrawal limits, and replacement costs?
- How much liquid money remains outside the contract for repairs, care, and changes in plans?
- How is everyone involved paid, and why is this choice preferable to the available alternatives?
A clear recommendation should answer those questions in ordinary language and in writing. Trust grows from a comparison you can examine, including the circumstances in which the recommendation would fail to fit. The aim is to strengthen the retirement plan as a whole, with a specific job for any contract you choose.
Sources and Review Date
Reviewed October 28, 2026. References: Official source: investor.gov · Official source: insurance.wa.gov. Examples are illustrative unless identified otherwise; account, contract, and state rules can affect the result.
Income Hydra™